Brendan
had been a part of my church for as long as I could remember and he and his
wife became good friends. I had told them about my struggle with cutting. They
were understanding and comforting. It wasn’t long until I felt like a part of
their family, going to their house for dinner, baking with their kids, going on
trips with them…
Until
March 8, 2009. I went to his house with a few other people for lunch. We had
fun and talked and hung out. It was a good day. That night, I was really upset
and considering cutting. I almost did. But I decided to call the Smith’s. I
trusted them with my life.
He quickly told me that he was
coming to pick me up on the next street over so that my parents wouldn’t wake
up. On the way to his house, it was almost silent as he occasionally looked
over at me and asked if I was okay. When we got to his house, all of the lights
were off. We went inside. I sat on the chair while he sat on the couch across
from me. Still oblivious to what was going on, I stayed silent and stared down
at my hands. When he sat staring at me for what seemed like hours, I finally
understood. I was angry. ”It’s my fault,
oh God, it’s my fault…make him stop, make it stop.” I kept repeating in my
mind, but I froze. At that point, I realized that everyone was going to change.
There was no rewinding.
Tears
ran down my face as he began to speak, “Silence, you are a beautiful and
attractive young lady. I am a man of God, but I am having extreme temptations
to comfort you in the way that a man would comfort his wife.”
My
heart dropped, “No, no, no! Get away from
me!” The words wouldn’t come out.
“I
want to comfort you”, he emphasized. “And if you feel uncomfortable at any
time, you can tell me to stop,” Brendan continued, locking his legal defense. He
slowly moved his hand to my left knee, careful not to make a sudden move. He
continued to fix his gaze on my eyes, probably wondering if I was going to look
up at him.
Reaching
out his other hand, both went to my waist, “come here”, he whispered,
indicating he wanted me to sit on his lap. My mind was spinning. I was aware of
what was happening, but I was caught up in blaming myself for it. I opened my
mouth, too afraid to look him in the eye. Even though I knew it would come out
shaky and in a whisper, I stood up for myself for the first time in my life,
“No.” He drew his hands back to his side and stared at me for a few minutes.
“Maybe I should take you home.”
From March to May, I pretended that
nothing happened. I didn’t go to their house any more, but everything else was
the same. Living in regret, I wished and prayed that it would be reversed. I
wanted my second family back.
Instead, they turned on me. Brendan
approached me after worship practice at the church, “hey, can I speak to you in
Pastor Fred’s office?”
“Uh, sure…” I nervously agreed.
I walked into Fred’s office, my
stomach in knots when I found him, Brendan, and Brendan’s wife staring at me
with concerned looks. I thought it was going to be some sort of intervention
for cutting.
I spoke up, “Can we do this another
day? I had a really bad day.”
They all sighed in pity as Fred
spoke, “I’m so sorry.” But they didn’t let me leave.
Fred was the first to say anything,
“Well, we’re here because Brendan needs to say a few words to you, Silence.”
He motioned to Brendan, “go ahead.”
Brendan sighed, “I’ve been spending
a lot of time thinking about you. It’s a little bit my fault and I understand
that, but you are getting in the way of my family life. I feel like I’m not a
very good father and husband. I need you to step away so that I can focus on my
family more.”
Fred stepped in, “Now, Silence, I’m
sure you didn’t mean to have bad intentions, but there’s obviously an issue. Do
you want to say anything?”
I shook my head as tears ran down my
face. Shock and disgust built up inside of me.
Fred prayed at the end of the
meeting and when he said “amen”, I bolted. I ran out of his office, out of the
church, as far as I could down that road. I bent over the gravel and heaved
until I collapsed and put my face in my hands. Was it me, or did he really just
blame me?
It was about a year later that I
decided to talk to Pastor Fred about it again. It was the night of AWANA, and I
knew that he’d be there playing the role of back up commander. At game time, I
paced in front of the sound booth in the sanctuary, not paying much attention
to my team hollering at their teammate that was running around the circle to
try to reach the pin in the middle before her competitors did.
“I can do this”, I repeated to
myself, being unsuccessful in convincing myself. Slowly sighing, I realized
nothing would calm my wildly beating heart. Leaving my team to my partner, I
sauntered off to the foyer; my palms grew sweatier as I neared my destination.
I entered Fred’s office as he
welcomed me with a smile. I resisted the urge to bolt, “I need to tell you
something.”
He motioned to the chair across from
him, practically the only thing in his office that wasn’t cluttered.
I sat as I took notice of the framed
bills on his wall from different countries. It had been there for years,
collecting dust along with all the other clutter on his shelves.
Fred kept typing as he spoke,
“what’s up?”
“Did Brendan ever tell you what
happened between us one night? He said some things that really upset me.” I
said it bluntly, just to get it out there.
He nodded as he said no, confusing
me. “Well…” I started to say. Fred looked away from his computer, “Well, I’m
sure it’s fine…how about you write down what you’re felling and I will read it
and see what happens.”
He was either clueless or didn’t
care. I nodded.
“Alright, perfect!” He slammed his
fists on his desk triumphantly, as if he had just done his good deed for the
day, “I’ll see you later!”
I stood up from the chair, feeling
defeated. I hurried back to my team, who was still sprinting in circles. In
frustration, I slammed my hand against the wall, catching the attention of the
blue team. I apologized and smiled and walked out of the church. And like
everything else in my life, I ignored it. So did Fred. I didn’t write, and he
didn’t ask.
And then I got an idea. I wanted
someone to listen to me. Drew had already proved that he cared. It was his job
to care, right? So I texted him, “Yeah, Fred blew me off when I tried to tell
him about what happened with Brendan that one night…” Quickly following that
text was another, “Oops! Sorry, I meant to send that to someone else!”
Brilliant, wasn’t it? But he didn’t
text back.
The next day, I had an appointment
with Drew at the police department because I had asked if I could interview him
for a class I was taking. After the interview, he asked about the text I sent
him about Brendan. He asked if he could bring in a victim advocate from ASPEN,
and I agreed. Her name was Cindy. I didn’t want to talk to her; I didn’t know
her. Her voice was high pitched, just enough to annoy me. Her hair was in
pigtails and she wore a long blue skirt. She smiled too much, but she was nice.
I
told them the sugar-coated version of the story and told him about how Fred
didn’t listen to me. He sighed in disbelief, “Nothing Brendan did was illegal,
but it was definitely wrong. I don’t want you to ever be alone with him again,
okay?” I agreed, immediately clamming up.
I sat in silence as he wrote a few
notes in his notepad. I listened as Cindy came up with a plan of action. Drew
would call Fred to tell him that what I had to say was important and Cindy
would come with me to tell Fred about it.
Drew took a breath, as if to say something
else. He hesitated as he looked at me with concern, “I’ve been doing this job
for a long time; I know there’s something you aren’t telling me.”
He was right, but I shook my head. I
was embarrassed.
As plans were made to meet with Fred
and the meeting grew closer, I was getting anxious. An hour before the
scheduled meeting, my phone rang, showing the number of ASPEN. I didn’t answer,
afraid that she was going to cancel. I held down the voicemail button as the
lady on the machine told me I had a message. Duh. My heart sank as I listened
to Cindy’s coworker explain that she wouldn’t be able to make it due to a
family emergency. Alone in my agony once again, my stomach churned as I ran out
of the church and threw my hands in the air, giving up. In the next hour, I
paced the parking lot, my stomach swelling with anxiety. If I was going to talk
to Fred, it had to be then. I knew myself better: I’d back down. I was at a
loss. I read the letter that I wrote to read to Fred over and over again in my
head until I practically memorized it.
As I was reading the letter for the
millionth time, I heard a car pull up. My heart leapt and I looked up. Carrie,
the worship leader, my friend, stepped out of her car. Sighed in relief,
tearing up, and asked her to come to the meeting with me. I couldn’t do it
alone.
I filled Carrie in and she agreed to
accompany me. Fred showed up a few minutes later, greeting us as he opened his
door. I told him about Cindy and he apologized.
I entered the cluttered office one
again, more nervous than ever. Pulling the folded paper out of my pocket, I
began to tremble. Carrie put her hand on mine, “it’s okay.”
I gave her a weak smile as I
unfolded the paper. It was slightly damp from my furiously sweating hands. I
shook with intensity while my stomach flipped over and over, threatening to empty
itself.
“You have the floor. No one will
speak until you are done. “Fred said to me.
I nodded, unsure if I wanted to go
through with it. I looked around at the cluttered, but welcoming office. I
looked at Carrie, who smiled and said, “go ahead.”
I took a deep breath and began to
read my own heart-wrenching words.
I told Fred that I was hurt; that I
felt insignificant. I told him what really happened with Brendan and how I felt
about it. I said things that I never thought that I would say.
When I was finished, I looked up and
saw the wide eyes of my pastor. He couldn’t believe it. He apologized and asked
me what I wanted to see be done.
Since I didn’t want anything to do
with Brendan, Fred suggested that I write a letter to him and Fred read it to
Brendan one on one. I agreed.
Finally, I had been listened to. For
once in my life, what I thought and said was significant. For once, I felt
relieved of this problem.
A week later, Fred announced that
Brendan was stepping down from the worship team to work things out. I was
relieved.
For a year, I avoided him and his
wife at church as if they were the plague. Then I heard some of the team
members talking about how someone was going to come back. No one would tell me
what was going on.
On Thursday, June 16th of
2011, I sat down in the conference room for the worship team meeting to start.
I watched everyone file in, taking their seats. Fred, Carrie, Drew, Mike, Flo,
Gina, Brendan… my heart leapt. Brendan?
My skin felt like it was going to
melt off, I was so warm. My heart raced as Fred began the meeting, “As you can
tell, Brendan is back on the team. He’s had a lot of time to work things out
and now he’s back with us!” Fred smiled and patted Brendan on the back. I was
furious. Fred knew my history and apprehension about Brendan, and no one told
me that he was coming back to the team. He shouldn’t have come back.
After the meeting, I ran outside and
leaned against the brick. Once I caught my breath, I walked away and vowed to
never go back. I wrote a letter both to the worship team and the elders about
why I was leaving the church for good.